Home

menu
A WBUR SPECIAL REPORT

BadChemistry

Annie Dookhan And The Massachusetts Drug Lab Crisis

Mass. High Court May Rule On Drug Lab Cases

News

A Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court justice has agreed to stay the potential release of a defendant convicted in a case in which evidence was tested by former chemist Annie Dookhan. It’s the first move in what is ultimately a case that questions the authority of the special magistrates who are reviewing cases involving the state drug lab crisis.

Essex County prosecutors asked (PDF) the high court to put off the stay of the man’s sentence until later this month, when they plan to file a motion that questions whether the magistrates have the power to stay sentences while motions for a new trial are pending. The sentences are for those convicted on evidence tested by Dookhan.

She has been charged with manipulating drug tests, potentially compromising tens of thousands of criminal cases. The state has set up special court sessions where magistrates are reviewing those cases. Hundreds of sentences have been stayed; dozens of defendants have been released.

The prosecutors asked for the stay as they prepare to file another motion this month, which, they say, “will raise substantial claims of irremediable error, or systemic misapplication of the law requiring the Court’s intervention.”

Supreme Judicial Court Justice Margot Botsford on Friday allowed (PDF) the prosecutors’ emergency motion to stay the defendant’s potential release, until further notice by the court. This is the first time the state’s highest court has taken up a case involving the drug lab crisis.

The defendant in this case pleaded guilty to drug and gun charges in 2010. In December, he asked for a new trial because the drugs were tested by Dookhan at the now-closed Hinton lab in Jamaica Plain. Last month, a special magistrate allowed a stay of his sentence and said he could be released on $5,000 bail with conditions such as wearing a GPS monitoring device.

- Related: Interview with Essex District Attorney Jonathan Blodgett:

Comments

Latest News

June 16, 2013

Data Analyst Describes Problems as Larger Than Dookhan

WBUR’s Deb Becker interviews Thomas Workman, a defense attorney and adjunct professor at the University of Massachusetts School of Law, who did his own analysis of the drug lab’s data.

June 14, 2013

Recent Brockton Violence Is Linked To Drug Lab Crisis

Three violent crimes in Brockton — including a brazen daytime murder — are linked to defendants who were released because of the state drug lab crisis.

June 11, 2013

Brockton Man, Released Amid Lab Crisis, Indicted For Murder

The indictment charges Donta Hood with fatally shooting Charles Evans in Brockton last month — eight months after Hood was released from prison.